From: Alan Riddell (peekee_at_blueyonder.co.uk)
Date: Fri Jan 24 2003 - 07:56:20 PST
Round Summary 201
====
Proposals
====
A B C D
==== ================
Jeff Weston A A ? A
Rich Holmes A A A A
Jonathan Amery F - - -
Andre A - - -
Karl Low A - - -
Stephen Turner A A A A
Factitious F - - -
Aron Wall - - F -
James Willson - - - F
Rules
====
Valid Date By
==== ==== ==== ====
201:1 Valid 01-24 06:17:05 Joshua
Eligibility
====
Joshua 01-31 06:17:05
All others 01-31 06:17:05
Full details are given below,
====
Round Proposals
====
Overrule proposal 201.A:
For the duration of round 201, R.O. 6 and 6a shall be replaced with
the following:
6. Judge. The Judge is responsible for interpreting the ordinances
and determining the validity of fantasy rules. If a fantasy rule
is inconsistent with the regular ordinances or with fewer or
greater than one member of the set consisting of itself and all
previously posted valid fantasy rules, then the Judge shall
declare that rule invalid or unsuccesful, otherwise e shall
declare it valid.
6a. A fantasy rule can only be declared unsuccesful if it is
inconsistent with more than one rule, and any of the rules it is
inconsistent with are other fantasy rules for which it is
reasonable to assume that the poster of the rule had not seen them
before e posted the rule.
====
Overrule proposal 201.B:
For the duration of round 201, R.O. 6 and 6a (or their replacement as
mandated by 201.A, if that proposal passes) shall be replaced with the
following:
6. Judge. The Judge is responsible for interpreting the ordinances
and determining the validity of fantasy rules. The Judge shall
declare a fantasy rule invalid or unsuccesful if any of the
following criteria are met:
a. The fantasy rule imposes a restriction that is impossible to
obey.
b. The set of rules consisting of the regular ordinances, the
fantasy rule, and all previously posted valid fantasy rules is
consistent.
c. One or more valid fantasy rules have been previously posted,
and there is no set of rules consisting of the regular ordinances,
the fantasy rule, and all but one of the previously posted valid
fantasy rules which is consistent.
Otherwise e shall declare that rule valid.
6a. A fantasy rule can only be declared unsuccesful if it meets any of
the criteria above, but would not meet any of the criteria above
if it were not for the presence of any previously posted fantasy
rules for which it is reasonable to assume that the poster of the
rule had not seen them before e posted the rule.
====
201:C
>>>>>>>
For this round only R.O. 6 shall be modified with respect to the
criteria for judging rules:
1) A rule shall be judged valid if it is consistent with itself, the
Regular Ordinances, and at least one rule from every minimal set of
previous valid rules that the most recent previous valid rule is
inconsistent with, and inconsistent with every maximal set of previous
valid rules that the most recent previous valid rule is consistent with.
2) If no previous rule is valid, a rule needs only to be consistent with
itself and the Regular Ordinances to be judged valid.
Otherwise it shall be judged invalid or unsuccessful.
3) A rule may only be judged unsuccessful if it is only not valid only
due to the existence of one or more rules for which it is reasonable to
believe that the poster did not see the rule(s).
>>>>>>>
====
Overrule proposal 201.C:
[Renumbered 201:D]
For the duration of round 201, R.O. 6 and 6a shall be replaced with the
following:
6. Judge. The Judge is responsible for interpreting the ordinances
and determining the validity of fantasy rules. The Judge shall
declare a fantasy rule invalid or unsuccesful if any of the
following criteria are met:
a. The fantasy rule is inconsistent with itself
c. The fantasy rule is inconsistent with more than half of
previous valid fantasy rules
c. One or more valid fantasy rules have been previously posted,
and there is no set of rules consisting of the regular ordinances,
the fantasy rule, and all but one of the previously posted valid
fantasy rules which is consistent.
Otherwise e shall declare that rule valid.
6a. A fantasy rule can only be declared unsuccesful if it meets any of
the criteria above, but would not meet any of the criteria above
if it were not for the presence of any previously posted fantasy
rules for which it is reasonable to assume that the poster of the
rule had not seen them before e posted the rule.
====
Round Rules
====
201:1
No VALID fantasy rule in this round may be consistant with all of the
restrictions in this Fantasy rule. All VALID Fantasy Rules Must be
written in English and sent by e-mail to frc_at_trolltech.com by members
of the Fantasy Rules Committee.
Please do not attach a signature to your rule.
====
--
Rule Date: 2003-01-24 15:56:38 GMT
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.5 : Thu Nov 24 2011 - 10:48 PST